Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

--- logo:top6 [2014/01/30 22:30] – muriel
+++ logo:top6 [2014/03/04 09:31] (current) – muriel
@@ Line 9: / Line 9: @@
-| Scoring | Logo | Manual | Criticisms |
+| | Scoring | Logo | Manual | Criticisms |
-| 10 points | {{ :logo:pp_eu_logo_v2.jpg?direct&200 |}} | {{:logo:pp_eu_logo_v2.pdf| Manual }} | Reminds of the European Union, but has it’s own  character. The Stars are dynamic, almost exploding. Very nice use of typography here, overall, a very balanced logo. Good to use on photographs. \\ Delivers the message with a very elegant style. Perfect finish. Too similar to the original logo when used toghether. Colour might be too classic. |
+|A| 10 points | {{ :logo:pp_eu_logo_v2.jpg?direct&200 |}} | {{:logo:pp_eu_logo_v2.pdf| Manual }} | Reminds of the European Union, but has it’s own  character. The Stars are dynamic, almost exploding. Very nice use of typography here, overall, a very balanced logo. Good to use on photographs. \\ Delivers the message with a very elegant style. Perfect finish. Too similar to the original logo when used toghether. Colour might be too classic. |
-| 9 points | {{ :logo:ppeu_2_.jpg?direct&200 |}} | {{:logo:ppeu_2_.zip| Manual }} | While the “European Pirates” is not readable, the visual language is nice, with bold letters. The Pirate sail forming an e with the circle doesn’t work that well, though. \\ Easy to identify, good complement of national pirate party logos. Clear and well finished. “EU”, if read as an acronym, might be misleading (just like the stars in other logos). \\ Good alternative to the stars, although the readability is low. |
+|B| 9 points | {{ :logo:ppeu_2_.jpg?direct&200 |}} | {{:logo:ppeu_2_.zip| Manual }} | While the “European Pirates” is not readable, the visual language is nice, with bold letters. The Pirate sail forming an e with the circle doesn’t work that well, though. \\ Easy to identify, good complement of national pirate party logos. Clear and well finished. “EU”, if read as an acronym, might be misleading (just like the stars in other logos). \\ Good alternative to the stars, although the readability is low. |
-| 8 points | {{ :logo:ppeu_logo_2_proposal.jpg?direct&200 |}} | {{:logo:ppeu_logo_2.zip| Manual }} | Too many elements (sail, flag, star), and putting a sail on a flag is not convincing. But it looks good. Would have been better with some colour. The Font might be hard to read. \\ Appealing. Would work well in conjunction with the original logo. The lack of colour makes it a bit too cold. \\ Well balanced, and it is nice not to see an evident star. Having two flags is weird. |
+|C| 8 points | {{ :logo:ppeu_logo_2_proposal.jpg?direct&200 |}} | {{:logo:ppeu_logo_2.zip| Manual }} | Too many elements (sail, flag, star), and putting a sail on a flag is not convincing. But it looks good. Would have been better with some colour. The Font might be hard to read. \\ Appealing. Would work well in conjunction with the original logo. The lack of colour makes it a bit too cold. \\ Well balanced, and it is nice not to see an evident star. Having two flags is weird. |
-| 5 points | {{ :logo:logoeur_b.jpg?direct&200 |}} | {{:logo:logoeur.zip| Manual }} | It’s ok, but would have been better with more colour. Could lose itself on photographs. \\ Concise and elegant use of the two predictable elements. It does not add much novelty, but would work well. |
+|D| 5 points | {{ :logo:logoeur_b.jpg?direct&200 |}} | {{:logo:logoeur.zip| Manual }} | It’s ok, but would have been better with more colour. Could lose itself on photographs. \\ Concise and elegant use of the two predictable elements. It does not add much novelty, but would work well. |
-| 4 points | {{ :logo:pp-eu-manual.jpg?direct&200 |}} | {{:logo:pp-eu-manual.pdf| Manual }} | The more conservative version of the 10 Points logo. Beautiful styleguide. Good to use on photographs. \\ Predictable. Correct but not attractive. |
+|E| 4 points | {{ :logo:pp-eu-manual.jpg?direct&200 |}} | {{:logo:pp-eu-manual.pdf| Manual }} | The more conservative version of the 10 Points logo. Beautiful styleguide. Good to use on photographs. \\ Predictable. Correct but not attractive. |
-| 4 points | {{ :logo:ppeu_logo_4_proposal.jpg?direct&200 |}} | {{:logo:ppeu_logo_4.zip| Manual }} | Minimalist in a positive way. Space for acronym does not allow many variations. \\ Does not add the idea of Europe to the original logo. Too plain. |
+|F| 4 points | {{ :logo:ppeu_logo_4_proposal.jpg?direct&200 |}} | {{:logo:ppeu_logo_4.zip| Manual }} | Minimalist in a positive way. Space for acronym does not allow many variations. \\ Does not add the idea of Europe to the original logo. Too plain. |
 Here you can find the [[ logo:regulation |call and regulations]] that were used for this selection process.
+And here you can find the [[ logo:results|results]].